December 29, 2019   |   by admin

tages of this account of indicative conditionals, and in section. 5 I reply to on Grice’s Views about the Logical Particles of Natural Language,” in Prag- matics of . if it is a valid inference, then the indicative conditional conclusion must be logically 3 H.P. Grice, in his William James lectures, 4 pursued the first of these . conditionals, but not those of indicative conditionals, are known to be false or at . of this view include Lewis [], Jackson [], [], and Grice [a]. 6.

Author: Gagore Faegis
Country: France
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Music
Published (Last): 19 May 2015
Pages: 288
PDF File Size: 19.54 Mb
ePub File Size: 6.63 Mb
ISBN: 251-3-76998-123-1
Downloads: 16805
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Yonos

On development, it appears to be incompatible with construing conditionals as statements with truth conditions.

See Gibbardpp. Suppose A 1Also this approach is somewhat unprincipled, using a kind of average of quite distinct kinds of thing: Do we escape Lewis’s result that a conditional probability is not the probability of conditioonals truth of any proposition, by making the proposition expressed by a conditional context-dependent?

Its main disadvantage is that the semantics is very complex: I gric be close to certain, but not completely certain, that Jane will accept if she is offered the job, that if I have the operation I will be cured, etc. The lines of a truth table constitute a partition. This is a work in cognitive psychology.


Material Conditional: Grice – Oxford Scholarship

It was Gibbardpp. Under the terms of the licence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of a monograph in OSO for personal use for details see www. We read 2 as equivalent to 1hence also unassailable. The antecedent of 2 entails its consequent. Let’s consider this as applied to a problem raised by McGee with the following example.

So by Import-Export, 1 is a logical truth.

Rani Lill Anjum, Paul Grice on Indicative Conditionals – PhilPapers

Grice drew attention, then, to conxitionals in which a person is justified in believing a proposition, which would nevertheless be an unreasonable thing for the person to sayin normal circumstances. However, in the wake of Lewis, Stalnaker himself proved this stronger result, for his conditional connective: One way of motivating this approach is to treat it as a refinement of Stalnaker’s truth conditions.

It is difficult to see why this should be so if conditionals are propositions with truth conditions. And if there are conditional propositions, it seems more natural to say that we now take to be true what we were previously wondering about.

The Material Conditional: Grice

This does not demonstrate that Hook is correct. So Stalnaker’s logic for conditionals must agree with Adams’s over their common domain. A supposition also grrice one’s claim to the case in which the antecedent is true. For the purpose of doing mathematics, Frege’s judgement was probably correct. My conditional probability for consequent given antecedent is high. But she might well accept if she is offered the job. Page references to Lewis The latter was the criterion Adams used in constructing his logic.


Indicative Conditionals

A is called the antecedent, C the consequent. One believes that B to the extent that one thinks B more likely than not B ; according to Supp, one believes that B if A to the extent that one believes that B under the supposition that Ai.

Was my remark true or false? Counterfactuals will be the subject of a separate entry, and theories addressing them will not be discussed here. He taught us something important about classically valid arguments as well: Modals and ConditionalsOxford: If the modal operator is an epistemic ‘must’, as she suggests, bare conditionals are a species of strict conditional — something like ‘all live A -possibilities are C -possibilities’.

On anyone’s account of conditionals, there will be circumstances when a conditional is justifiably believed, but is liable to mislead if stated. Justin Khoo – – Philosophical Perspectives 27 1: